Daktilo 1984Daktilo 1984
    • Hakkımızda
    • İletişim
    • E-Bültene Abone Ol
    Facebook Twitter Instagram Telegram
    Twitter Facebook YouTube Instagram WhatsApp
    Daktilo 1984Daktilo 1984
    Destek Ol Abone Ol
    • İZLE
      • Çavuşesku’nun Termometresi
      • Varsayılan Ekonomi
      • 2’li Görüş
      • İki Savaş Bir Yazar
      • Yakın Tarih
      • Mayhoş Muhabbetler
      • Tümünü Gör
    • OKU
      • Yazılar
      • Röportajlar
      • Çeviriler
      • Asterisk2050
      • Yazarlar
    • DİNLE
      • Çerçeve
      • Zedcast
      • Tuhaf Zamanların İzinde
      • SenSensizsin
      • Tümünü Gör
    • D84 FYI
      • Hariçten Gazel
      • Avrupa Gündemi
      • ABD Gündemi
      • Altüst
    • D84 INTELLIGENCE
      • Kitap Yorum
      • Göç Sorunu
      • Başkanlık Sistemi Projesi
      • Devlet Kapasitesi Liberteryenizmi
      • Herkes için Siyaset Bilimi
      • Yapay Zeka
    Daktilo 1984Daktilo 1984
    Anasayfa » Turkey’s Currency Crisis: Is It Really The Economy, Stupid?
    Yazılar

    Turkey’s Currency Crisis: Is It Really The Economy, Stupid?

    Burak Bilgehan Özpek7 Şubat 20225 dk Okuma Süresi
    Paylaş
    Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Email WhatsApp

    It is not unusual to assume a correlation between the rise of the autocracy and the fall of the Turkish lira over the past two decades. In the first decade of the 2000s, the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) was seen as the democratizing force in Turkish politics, which has been under the tutelage of the Turkish military since 1961. During this period, the Turkish economy performed well and GDP per capita increased significantly. Meanwhile, Turkey was making reforms to obtain membership status from the European Union. Most of the intellectuals, academics and policy analysts believed that Turkey was moving towards a consolidated liberal democracy. Such achievements helped the AKP to weaken the military’s role in the system. The military elites were skeptical of the AKP from the very beginning, as the party elite came from the political Islamist tradition.

    Following the withdrawal of the military, the AKP’s charismatic leader Erdoğan has gradually established his personal rule. In doing so, he has eliminated rival factions in the AKP, increased his grip over media, academia, civil society and business circles and exploited national security issues to intimidate the opposition parties. In the second decade of its rule, the AKP has turned into a private company owned by Erdoğan. In addition, after the transition from the parliamentary system to the presidential system in April 2017, Erdoğan’s personality and the institutional identity of the state overlapped. However, building an indisputable personal cult did not bring him success in the field of economy. Since the presidential system referendum in 2017, the Turkish lira has depreciated significantly against foreign currencies. While the value of 1 US dollar against the Turkish lira was 3.6 on the day of the referendum, it decreased to 13.9 in January 2021. Similarly, GDP per capita fell from USD 10,589 in 2017 to USD 8,537 in 2020. According to the Turkish Statistical Institute, annual inflation is 48 percent and most Turks believe real inflation is above this. (See: https://www.justsecurity.org/79306/might-the-turkish-electorate-be-ready-to-say-goodbye-to-erdogan-after-two-decades-in-power/)

    As mentioned earlier, it is widely believed that there is a causal link between authoritarianism and economic failure. But unlike Erdogan’s Turkey, there are also some autocratic regimes where economies perform consistently. For example, such dramatic fluctuations are not common in Russia, China or Singapore, which are not classified as democratic regimes. This is because even autocracies see the economy as an autonomous field and recognize the autonomy of bureaucrats and experts. On the other hand, the Turkish economy suffers from lack of institutional capacity and bureaucratic autonomy.

    If it is not autocracy, what is the problem of Turkey? To answer this question we have to visit Francis Fukuyama who excludes “democratic accountability from the definition of governance”.  To him, governance refers to a government’s capacity to make rules and enforce them regardless of its regime type. In addition to that a government is expected to deliver services in an efficient way. For this reason, he sees the Weberian understanding of the state, which is based on the principles of the rule of law and bureaucratic autonomy, as the ideal type of governance. (See: https://www.cgdev.org/sites/default/files/1426906_file_Fukuyama_What_Is_Governance.pdf) From this point of view, the reason for the depreciation of the Turkish lira and the rapid decline in GDP per capita is the absence of the modern state rather than autocracy.

    Following the transition to presidential system, the state apparatus has lost its neutrality and turned into a private property of Erdoğan and his inner circle. Rules and laws have been differently enforced on citizens in accordance with their political engagements. This means that Erdogan’s critics are punished even if they exercise their constitutional rights, while Erdogan’s supporters are mostly exempt from legal sanctions even if they commit crimes. This indicates how judiciary is under Erdoğan’s control. In addition, bureaucratic institutions are run by individuals who lack technical competence and are partisanly loyal to Erdoğan. For example, 68 university rectors appointed by Erdoğan have no international publication. (See: https://www.cumhuriyet.com.tr/haber/68-rektorun-sifir-yayini-var-1707261) Likewise, Erdogan bypassed the bureaucratic tradition of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and appointed 25 ambassadors with clear ties to the AKP.  (See: https://www.cumhuriyet.com.tr/haber/buyukelci-atamalarindan-dikkat-cekici-ayrinti-akpli-eski-vekil-baku-buyukelcisi-1825405) Above all, Erdogan did not allow the Central Bank to take decisions in accordance with its legal responsibility to ensure price stability. He replaced three Central Bank governors last year and most recently appointed Şahap Kavcıoğlu, a former AKP deputy and columnist for Yeni Şafak Newspaper close to the government. Erdogan’s interventions in bureaucracy, combined with his arbitrary use of state banks and the Turkey Wealth Fund, which owns state-owned companies and assets, both weakened the state’s institutional capacity and destabilized the economy. In summary, the currency crisis in Turkey is not an economic problem stemming from the democratic decline. It is about the absence of the modern state, which has been eroded by Erdogan’s personal rule. Therefore, the Turkish economy can only recover in the future if such a state crisis is resolved instead of taking temporary and tactical economic measures.

    Fotoğraf:  Ibrahim Rifath 

    Siyaset
    Paylaş Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Email WhatsApp
    Önceki İçerikNightmare Alley (2021)
    Sonraki İçerik Sembollerin Esiri Olmak: Kimlik Siyasası Üzerine Bir Değini

    Diğer İçerikler

    Yazılar

    Yeni Anayasa Yeni Türkiye Demek Değil

    30 Mayıs 2025 Armağan Öztürk
    Yazılar

    Komünizmin Rıza Nur’u: Aclan Sayılgan

    28 Mayıs 2025 Kadir Serkan Selçuk
    Videolar

    Parlamenter Sistem için Yol Ayrımında mıyız? | Berk Esen | Çavuşesku’nun Termometresi ÖZEL #255

    28 Mayıs 2025 Berk Esen, Burak Bilgehan Özpek, İlkan Dalkuç ve Melis Konakçı

    Yorumlar kapalı.

    Güncel İçerikler

    Yeni Anayasa Yeni Türkiye Demek Değil

    30 Mayıs 2025 Yazılar Armağan Öztürk

    Komünizmin Rıza Nur’u: Aclan Sayılgan

    28 Mayıs 2025 Yazılar Kadir Serkan Selçuk

    Dünya Gündemi: ABD-AB Gümrük Müzakereleri, Rusya’dan Ukrayna’ya Yeni Hava Saldırısı, Venezuela Seçimleri

    27 Mayıs 2025 Bültenler Bahadır Çelebi

    Krizler Çağında Umut Ekmek: Gençler Gıdanın Geleceğini Geri Alıyor

    26 Mayıs 2025 Yazılar Elif Menderes

    E-Bültene Abone Olun

    Güncel içeriklerden ilk siz haberdar olun




    Archives

    • Mayıs 2025
    • Nisan 2025
    • Mart 2025
    • Şubat 2025
    • Ocak 2025
    • Aralık 2024
    • Kasım 2024
    • Ekim 2024
    • Eylül 2024
    • Ağustos 2024
    • Temmuz 2024
    • Haziran 2024
    • Mayıs 2024
    • Nisan 2024
    • Mart 2024
    • Şubat 2024
    • Ocak 2024
    • Aralık 2023
    • Kasım 2023
    • Ekim 2023
    • Eylül 2023
    • Ağustos 2023
    • Temmuz 2023
    • Haziran 2023
    • Mayıs 2023
    • Nisan 2023
    • Mart 2023
    • Şubat 2023
    • Ocak 2023
    • Aralık 2022
    • Kasım 2022
    • Ekim 2022
    • Eylül 2022
    • Ağustos 2022
    • Temmuz 2022
    • Haziran 2022
    • Mayıs 2022
    • Nisan 2022
    • Mart 2022
    • Şubat 2022
    • Ocak 2022
    • Aralık 2021
    • Kasım 2021
    • Ekim 2021
    • Eylül 2021
    • Ağustos 2021
    • Temmuz 2021
    • Haziran 2021
    • Mayıs 2021
    • Nisan 2021
    • Mart 2021
    • Şubat 2021
    • Ocak 2021
    • Aralık 2020
    • Kasım 2020
    • Ekim 2020
    • Eylül 2020
    • Ağustos 2020
    • Temmuz 2020
    • Haziran 2020
    • Mayıs 2020
    • Nisan 2020
    • Mart 2020
    • Şubat 2020
    • Ocak 2020
    • Aralık 2019
    • Kasım 2019
    • Ekim 2019
    • Eylül 2019
    • Ağustos 2019
    • Temmuz 2019
    • Haziran 2019
    • Mayıs 2019
    • Nisan 2019
    • Mart 2019

    Categories

    • Asterisk2050
    • Bültenler
    • Çeviriler
    • D84 INTELLIGENCE
    • EN
    • Forum
    • Özetler
    • Podcast
    • Röportajlar
    • Uncategorized
    • Videolar
    • Yazılar
    Konular
    • Siyaset
    • Ekonomi
    • Dünya
    • Tarih
    • Kültür Sanat
    • Spor
    • Rapor
    • Gezi
    İçerik
    • Yazılar
    • Podcast
    • Forum
    • Röportajlar
    • Çeviriler
    • Özetler
    • Bültenler
    • D84 INTELLIGENCE
    Konular
    • Siyaset
    • Ekonomi
    • Dünya
    • Tarih
    • Kültür Sanat
    • Spor
    • Rapor
    • Gezi
    Sosyal Medya
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Youtube
    • LinkedIn
    • Apple Podcast
    • Spotify Podcast
    • Whatsapp Kanalı
    Kurumsal
    • Anasayfa
    • Hakkımızda
    • İletişim
    • Yazarlar
    • İçerik Sağlayıcılar
    • Yayın İlkeleri ve Yazım Kuralları
    © 2025 DAKTİLO1984
    • KVKK Politikası
    • Çerez Politikası
    • Aydınlatma Metni
    • Açık Rıza Beyanı

    Arama kelimesini girin ve Enter'a tıklayın. İptal etmek için Esc'ye tıklayın.

    Çerezler

    Sitemizde mevzuata uygun şekilde çerez kullanılmaktadır.

    Fonksiyonel Her zaman aktif
    Sitenin çalışması için ihtiyaç duyulan çerezlerdir
    Preferences
    The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
    İstatistik
    Daha iyi bir kullanıcı deneyimi sağlamak için kullanılan çerezlerdir The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
    Pazarlama
    Size daha uygun içeriklerin iletilmesi için kullanılan çerezlerdir
    Seçenekleri yönet Hizmetleri yönetin {vendor_count} satıcılarını yönetin Bu amaçlar hakkında daha fazla bilgi edinin
    Seçenekler
    {title} {title} {title}